Why are class action settlement checks so small? The real math

Why are class action settlement checks so small? The short version

A class action settlement creates a common fund — a pot of money the defendant pays to end the case. Before a single class member is paid, the court-approved settlement agreement sets an order of payments that works like a waterfall:

1. Attorneys' fees and litigation costs — requested by class counsel, approved (and sometimes trimmed) by the judge.
2. Notice and administration costs — mailing postcards, sending emails, running the claims website and call center, validating claims, cutting checks. This goes to the settlement administrator.
3. Service awards — modest payments to the named plaintiffs who carried the case (see what a lead plaintiff does).
4. Class members — whatever is left, divided by the number of valid claims (pro rata) or paid as a fixed amount per person until the money runs out.

That's why a settlement advertised as "$92 million" and a check for $38 can both be true at the same time. None of it is hidden: every step is in the long-form notice and the court's final approval order, usually posted on the settlement website.

Attorneys' fees: 25–33% off the top

Class actions are almost always run on contingency: the lawyers front years of work and get paid only if they win or settle. Rule 23(h) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lets the court award "reasonable attorney's fees and nontaxable costs," and judges use two methods to decide what's reasonable:

• Percentage of the fund. The most common approach in consumer cases. Awards cluster around 25–33%, and some courts (the Ninth Circuit, for example) start from a 25% "benchmark" and adjust up or down. A widely cited empirical study by Vanderbilt law professor Brian Fitzpatrick found fee awards with a mean and median of roughly 25% of the settlement.
• Lodestar. Hours worked × a reasonable hourly rate, sometimes multiplied for risk. Often used as a cross-check on the percentage.

Percentages tend to fall as funds get bigger — a $1 billion settlement rarely pays 33% — but in the $5–$100 million range where most consumer cases live, 25–30% is typical. Our guide on how much class action lawyers make walks through the approval process and some real awards.

Notice, administration and service awards

Someone has to tell millions of people a settlement exists, build the claims site, catch duplicate and fraudulent claims, answer the phone and mail the checks. That work is done by a court-appointed administrator (Epiq, Kroll, Angeion, JND, Verita and a handful of others) and is paid from the fund. For large settlements it's typically a low single-digit percentage; for small funds with big classes it can eat a much larger share, because postage and processing cost the same per person whether the check is $5 or $500.

Service awards (also called incentive awards) go to the named plaintiffs — typically a few thousand dollars each, occasionally more. They rarely move the per-person math much, but they come out before you do.

Then there's the quiet killer: uncashed checks. A meaningful share of settlement checks are never deposited, which is one reason administrators increasingly push digital payments. What happens to that money is covered below.

Claim rates and pro-rata dilution

Most consumer settlements are pro rata: the net fund is divided by the number of valid claims. That makes your check a function of how many people bother to file. A 2019 Federal Trade Commission staff study of 149 consumer class action settlements found a median claims rate of 9% and a weighted mean of just 4% — and campaigns that mailed full notice packets did best (median 16%), while email-only campaigns did worst.

Two consequences follow:

• When a settlement goes viral and claim rates spike, checks shrink. "Up to $X" on the claim form is a cap, not a promise; see how much no-proof settlements really pay.
• When few people file — common in proof-required claims — each valid claim gets a bigger slice, and some settlements then run a second distribution of leftover money to the people who already claimed.

Flat-payment settlements (a fixed $10 or $15 per person, like the Starbucks mobile-order fee settlement or the DoorDash hidden-fee settlement) avoid dilution until the fund is exhausted, at which point payments are reduced proportionally anyway.

Worked example: where a $92 million fund actually goes

Take a $92 million fund — the size of the TikTok privacy settlement on our TikTok settlement page — and run it through a typical waterfall. The percentages below are illustrative, not the actual orders in that case:

Cy pres, reversion and second distributions

Not all the money allocated to class members gets cashed. Checks expire, emails bounce, people move. Settlement agreements spell out what happens to the residue, and it matters for your check:

• Second distribution. Leftover funds are split again among people who cashed their first check. Best case for claimants.
• Cy pres. From the French cy près ("as near as possible"): the residue goes to a nonprofit whose mission relates to the case — a privacy foundation in a privacy case, for instance. Courts allow it when further distribution isn't practical.
• Reversion. Unclaimed money goes back to the defendant. Judges increasingly dislike this because it rewards low claim rates, but it still appears, especially in claims-made settlements with no fixed fund.

Details in what happens to unclaimed settlement money. The practical point: a no-proof claim that takes two minutes can pay out twice if enough people ignore their checks.

How to get a bigger share of any settlement

You can't change the fee award, but you can change which side of the math you're on:

• File the proof-required claims. Fewer people file them, caps are higher, and documented losses are often paid dollar-for-dollar. The Bank of America data breach settlement pays a flat $50 with no proof but up to $600 for documented losses — see our data breach settlements guide.
• Know when you're in a subclass. Illinois residents in biometric cases, early purchasers, or account holders during a specific period often get weighted shares; read the notice's payment section.
• File everything you qualify for. Ten $30 claims beat one $300 hope. Browse the settlements directory or let Owed match and file them for free.
• Don't opt out over a small check. Opting out only makes sense when your individual damages are large — see what opting out means.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice.

Glossary

Common fund

The pot of money a defendant pays to settle a class action; fees, costs and class payments all come out of it.

Percentage-of-the-fund

A fee method where class counsel receives a court-approved share (often 25–33%) of the common fund.

Lodestar

Hours worked multiplied by a reasonable hourly rate; used to set or cross-check attorneys' fees.

Pro rata

A distribution where the net fund is divided among valid claims, so each share shrinks as more people claim.

Claims rate

The percentage of eligible class members who actually submit a claim; FTC research puts the median near 9%.

Cy pres

A court-approved donation of leftover settlement money to a nonprofit related to the case when further distribution is impractical.

FAQ